Thursday, October 25, 2012

Homeland. Truth Troubles


by Gloria Origgi and Ariel Colonomos. Published on the Berlin Review of Books, december 17th 2012.



And ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free.
John 8:32

This passage of the Bible is inscribed on the marble walls of the lobby of the CIA Headquarters in Langley, Virginia. After passing through heavy security, this is probably the first thing visitors entering the building would see. Homeland – the 2012 award-winning American TV series – Obama’s favourite, we are being told – raises one important question: What is, then, the price to be paid for knowing such truth?

“I have never been so sure and so wrong”. This line in the mouth of Carrie – a manic bipolar CIA officer determined to stop Nicholas Brody, a former Marine and prisoner of war, who has been released from Iraq after eight years of torture and has been “turned” by Al-Qaeda – is the quintessence of the whole series, now in its second season.
Homeland brings together two essential dimensions of truth and identity, in a breathtaking superposition of identity of the self and political identity. The two main characters – Carrie and Brody – have both multiple identities. Carrie goes through phases of mania and depression. At the peaks of her condition – when she is hyperactive or utterly dejected – she delivers essential truths about the identity of her counterpart, Brodie, and about the future of the United States.

Brodie is Carrie’s enemy and her raison d’être. As such, naturally, he becomes her lover. Brodie is an equally ambiguous character. He has been turned, yet not completely: as such, he is a classic case of double allegiance. He is a congressman and yet is ready to blow himself up in a room where the top US military and the vice-president are gathered. Brodie is the reflection of the fantasies of the West, whose patriots fear being invaded from within by their natural enemies: Muslim fundamentalists. Last but not least, Brodie is also bisexual, another fear of the “enemy within”, i.e. the deep drives of the unconscious we all have to deal with. Believe it or not (for anyone who has not watched the show, this might seem a bit of a stretch), Brodie has been sexually ‘turned’ by US number one public enemy, Abu Nazir – a fancy Bin Laden.

There is no truth without ambivalence. This is the striking message carried by Homeland. Heroes are also traitors, and masters of intelligence are also delusional. Yet, there is something special in the way in which ambivalence is staged here: the essential dramatic texture of the whole story is based on the fundamental ambivalence not only of the characters, but of the values they embody and of the emotions they solicit in us. As if the series was able to broadcast the slow but inevitable loss of the monopoly of truth – the Good Truth, the Right Truth, the one we attain through the appropriate methods – which America is facing today.

Carrie is a modern oracle. Her outstanding ability to track the truth is invaluable, and her bosses at the CIA know this very well. Yet, her methods are sometimes odd, based on intuition instead of evidence, and her style of inquiry too disrespectful of rules. She allows herself to make unauthorized moves in order to come up with results, thereby putting herself and the CIA at risk. At the same time, she is a very attractive woman, with a restless mind of rare subtlety.

Brody is the mirror image of Carrie’s ambivalent truth: he has actually been turned by Abu Nazir, but now that he is back, he hesitates, goes back and forth, from the horrible tortures he underwent in Iraq, to the memories of the discovery of a new world of values with Abu Nazir, who protected him, helped him and became his lover. His being turned touches upon all the dimensions of his life: psychological, sexual, political and religious. When – at the beginning of season 2 – his wife discovers that he prays as a Muslim, she exclaims in horror: “This just can’t happen!”.

Brody elicits in us mixed feelings: we are horrified by the intolerant and narrow-minded reaction of his wife, who cannot acknowledge another religious credo, but are also horrified when we discover that he is actually ready to kill the vice-president. Yet, his reasons for losing faith in his country are the killing of civilians, including children – notably, of Abu Nazir’s son.

Brody’s truth is unstable, Carrie’s truth is volatile, and the audience is trapped in their ambivalent posture, going back and forth between heroism and cowardice, between objective truth and intuition, between reasons that are too many in number, yet seem all in all plausible.
What is shocking to an audience of our generation is that, for the first time, a U.S. TV show puts on stage the duplicity of truth, as if discriminating between good and evil were a long by gone endeavour. And this state of permanent moral ambivalence permeates the psyche of the audience to the point of exhaustion: we simply cannot bear such an uncertain world. We oscillate between the two sides of the truth as the plot unfolds through a series of spectacular turns and twists that are the mirror of this feeling of instability.

Carrie and Brodie are imprisoned in their double truths and are looking for a way out. They disturb the certainties of the people around them. They also dissolve the simplistic commitment to “The Truth” and “The Good” of the other characters. Indeed, the other characters are monoliths by comparison. Thus, Carrie’s mentor is a (good Jewish) father figure, Saul Berenson, who has just broken up with his wife, an Indian woman, whom we see (towards the middle of season 1) leaving her husband to return “home”. There was no place to stay for her in Saul’s patriotic and monastic life in Washington DC. Brodie’s wife is middle-class America at its best, with all its limitations. Her truth is simple and transparent. She strives for stability and a linear career that will land her husband in the White House (and, as for herself, will ultimately allow her to host charity dinners with the wives of other DC power brokers).

The uncertainty of the global order becomes the psychical instability of its subjects, in a sort of “collective manic-depression” in which we can no longer choose the right course of action, but can only oscillate permanently between a two-sided truth. Ironically, during the Cold War, bipolarity was used to refer to the stability of the balance of power that ruled the relation between the Soviet Union and the United States. In the post-9/11 era, bipolarity is internalized in the deep instability of the self, which reflects the trouble relation between the US and its ‘devils du jour’, both internal and external.

Homeland reminds us that the moral and political order of our world and its cognitive/epistemic order are impossible to disentangle. The ‘homeland’ that we all miss today is the homeland of a simple objective truth about how things are and how they should be. A truth that used to reassure us and made our decisions and actions grounded on a firm footing. As Odysseus already knew, outside our lost homeland, there is hell, permanent doubt and, in the end, loss. 

35 comments:

Unknown said...

This is the very good idea! Just want to say thank you for information, Just continue to the write such a position.Best advertising Agency in the world | top advertising agencies in pakistan | Marketing Agency

Jenniffer said...

Your blog is great. I love enjoying the reading

rachel said...

Your blog very informative. Being a school teacher these blogs really help me out

singapore assignment help said...

your blog post is fanatic.. we provide pay someone to do my assignment services in singapore

kristen said...

Many thanks for the exciting blog posting! Simply put your blog post to my favorite blog list and will look forward for additional updates. Canada Assignment Help Simply wanted to write down a word in order to say thanks to you for those wonderful tips.

james stephens said...

Thanks for this article. It contains the information i was searching for and you have also explained it well. assignment writing

Naveen said...

I know how your this amazing post can help you improve our knowledge and you are working hard so keep do it and I also share your post on my social account with another info like "best antivirus for windows 8.1" even you should read it once.

SophiaMiller said...

hello,
this is Sophia Miller.
this is a nice post, thanks for sharing.
Get the best perdisco assignment help in Australia.

Unknown said...

Hello
This is jessica jones, Thanks for Sharing this.


Best Web and Mobile Application solution provider Locus Rags in India.



Web Solution Winners said...

Thanks a lot for the kind of perfect topic I have not a lot of information about it but I have got an extra unique info in your unique post. Visit my blog Web Solution Winner Read More Web Solution Winner Blog UK

Susan said...

You have worked admirably on this article. It's truly meaningful and profoundly wise. You have even figured out how to make it justifiable and simple to peruse. You have some genuine composition ability. Much thanks to you
sims 4 news

amanda stephanie said...

Nice blog. Thanks for making it available to read.
College Essays Help

pesh said...

Thank you for sharing such an informative information. I like it and recommend to others. In case you are searching for capstone project writers search no more for Capstone Writing Help delivers quality and 100% plagiarism free work make your order now.

Assignment Help said...

Thanks for sharing the blog. It's great.
Physics Assignment Help

Leo5 said...

Thanks for sharing such insights. Great work. Much appreciated another info is also useful.
Unlock Bootloader Of Sony Xperia

Unknown said...

Get the best fitness band under 5000 in india to track fitness activity trackers
under 5000 that you can buy to track fitness. best fitness tracker under 5000

Mihir Mane said...

Find job openings for influencers, best bloggers, painters, writers, anchors across India.Hire top models for modeling in fashion shows, singers, freelance actors, photographers, cinematographer, bloggers in India. jobs for singers

sanjupawar said...

Know what the trending news is going on all across. Know what is trending on social media and on other social media platforms. upcoming web series

georgefernandis said...

Looking for the best attitude, love, good morning, life, funny, sad, friendship quotes & status. Here you can get the best quotes of all time. quotes in hindi

archi said...

Understand here what is digital marketing meaning in hindi, digital marketing kya
hota hai. Read for more details. best microwave convection oven

Mobtekvat said...

Highland Sauna & Spa is a high-quality massages, skin & body treatment provider with the tranquil facility. The spa has therapists who are licensed, professionally trained, and will respect all personal and professional boundaries.massage spa noida

Mobtekvat said...

The Lotus Spa, New Delhi: See review
full body massage in noida
sarticles, and photos of The ... All Inclusive Day Trip to Taj Mahal, Agra Fort and Baby Taj from.The Lotus Spa enhances the massage with its Aroma Stone Therapy program.

قیمت سیم کارت همراه اول said...

سایت خرید و فروش سیم کارت رندباز

ادرس اتاق فرار تهران said...

مجموعه اتاق فرار انیگما متشکل از تیمی خلاق، توانمند و حرفه‌ای، تلاش نموده است تا با رعایت استانداردهای بین المللی چه به جهت طراحی پلان بازی و چه به جهت طراحی داخلی و فضاها، ساعتی خوش را برای شما، دوستان و خانواده تان رقم بزند.

فروش اقساطی سیم کارت دائمی همراه اول said...

سایت رندباز در زمینه ی خرید و فروش سیم کارت فعالیت دارد
فروش فوری سیم کارت در رندباز
خرید قسطی سیم کارت در رندباز
خرید قسطی سیم کارت 912 در رندباز
قیمت گذاری سیم کارت در رندباز
و… همگی از خدمات سایت رندباز بوده.

Mobtekvat said...

Offering a wide range of rejuvenating spa therapies, the Lotus Day Spa in Gurgaon's Sector 18 Lotus Spa In Noida is just the place you need to be heading to for a blissfully. The Lotus Spa, New Delhi: See reviews, articles, and photos of The All Inclusive Day Trip.

Mesmerize Spa & Wellness Wellness said...

24 Hours Body Massage Centres Kolkata.This luxury spa in Kolkata offers massages and beauty treatments.body massage spa in Kolkata It offers some of the best body spa services in Kolkata. When you select Full Body to Body Massage by Female,

Best Services said...

This book is very helpful for me. It has a lot of informative news. Keep this spirit up and share more articles. "Now it's time to avail Taxi Stratford upon Avon for more information."

jameesstarrc said...

Thank you for sharing such an informative information. I like it and recommend to others. Great work. Much appreciated another info is also useful.Now it's time to avail Locksmith Leeds for more information.

Irelandassignmenthelper said...

Get professional help with online exams from Ireland Assignment Helper. Our experienced writers are available 24/7 to provide you with the best possible service. We guarantee original content, free revisions, and timely delivery. You'll also receive a free plagiarism check and have the option for unlimited revisions until you're completely satisfied. Contact us today for a stress-free online exam experience!

Gary sobers said...

Thanks for sharing this informative article with us. I do endorse your ideas you have presented in this article. I must applaud your work. Keep sharing like this. Now its time to avail https://boisecabservice.com/"> for more information.

shane said...

Thanks a lot for the kind of perfect topic I have not a lot of information about it but I have got an extra unique info in your unique post. I simply couldn't leave your site just my reading this blog. I am really impressed with the content and way of writing. Keep sharing more.
code of virginia emergency protective order
attorney to contest protective order virginia

Gary sobers said...

Thanks for sharing this informative article with us. It is a nice interesting content. Nice post. Keep it up the good work mate in this article. Now its time to avail Best 10 seat minibus hire in Dartford for more information.

Diploma Assignment Help said...

Struggling with history assignments? Our online platform delivers reliable history assignment help UK. From in-depth research to polished writing, our experts cover it all. Benefit from our commitment to quality and timely delivery. Get in touch for comprehensive online history assignment assistance that ensures your academic success.

Mobile App Development Company in Bangalore said...

Thank you very nice sharing.